How is order maintained in Statement based replication in SQL?

In Statement-Based Replication (SBR), the order of entries in the replication log is always maintained to ensure consistency between the primary (master) and replica (slave)

Maintaining the order of statements is critical because the state of the database at any given time depends on the exact sequence of operations.

Why Is Order Maintenance Important?

1. Causal Dependency:

   • SQL statements often depend on the results of previous statements. If the order is not maintained, the replica's state can become inconsistent with the primary.

     INSERT INTO employees (id, name, salary) VALUES (1, 'Alice', 50000);
     UPDATE employees SET salary = 60000 WHERE id = 1;
     

If the UPDATE statement is executed before the INSERT on the replica, it will fail because the row does not yet exist.

Transaction Atomicity:

• Statement-based replication typically replicates the entire transaction (if using transactional databases) in the same order as it was committed on the primary.

BEGIN;
UPDATE accounts SET balance = balance - 100 WHERE id = 1;
UPDATE accounts SET balance = balance + 100 WHERE id = 2;
COMMIT;

• If these statements are executed out of order on the replica, the balances may become inconsistent.

• Determinism Across Nodes:

  • The replica must re-execute SQL statements in the exact order they occurred on the primary to ensure deterministic results.

How Is Order Maintained?

1. Binary Log in Primary:

   • The primary database writes all SQL statements to the binary log in the exact order they are executed.

   • These statements include both transactional (COMMIT) and non-transactional queries, ensuring that all operations are logged sequentially.

2. Replication Process:

   • Replication threads on the replica fetch and replay the binary logs in the exact order in which they were written by the primary.

3. Transactional Grouping:

   • For transactional databases, an entire transaction (all its statements) is written to the binary log and replicated together. This ensures atomicity and consistency.

---

Scenarios Where Order Maintenance Matters

1. Dependent Operations:

   • Example

     INSERT INTO orders (id, product) VALUES (1, 'Laptop');
     UPDATE orders SET product = 'Desktop' WHERE id = 1;
     DELETE FROM orders WHERE id = 1;
     

     If the statements are not executed in order, the UPDATE or DELETE operations may fail on the replica because the required row might not exist.
     

   Non-Transactional Tables:

   • For non-transactional tables (e.g., MyISAM in MySQL), each statement is applied immediately. The exact sequence of statements is critical to maintaining consistency.

2. Cross-Statement Dependencies:

   • If one statement depends on data modified by a previous statement, maintaining the order is crucial.

---

Edge Cases Where Problems Can Arise

Although SBR ensures order is maintained, there are still potential issues to be aware of:

1. Non-Deterministic Statements:

   • Even if the order is maintained, non-deterministic statements like NOW(), RAND(), or UUID() can produce different results on replicas.

   • Example:

INSERT INTO events (id, timestamp) VALUES (1, NOW());

The NOW() function will generate different values on the primary and the replica, even though the statement order is preserved.

1. Time Zone or Locale Differences:

   • If the replica has a different time zone or locale configuration, deterministic behavior may break despite maintaining statement order.

---

Summary

In Statement-Based Replication (SBR):

• Order of entries is always maintained to ensure consistency and correctness.

• The replication process replays SQL statements in the exact sequence they were executed on the primary.

• Maintaining order is critical for handling dependencies, transactions, and non-transactional operations.

source:-wikipedia